Dr. Vera Delnon proposes Swiss State’s Claim against Germany at the ICJ

In 2008 Germany officially announced to have paid EUR 4.2 million for criminally acquired tax data from Liechtenstein. Subsequently, and with media coverage, German officials used these data in lawsuits against their own citizens (e.g. against the former chairman of the managing board of the Deutsche Post). At the same time German Government representatives called out on fighting tax havens and signaled to have „massive interest“ in further banking data of potential German tax evaders. Dr. Delnon then warned against baiting criminals and against illegal assaults by foreign government agencies. She carefully monitored the potentially dangerous development against the background of State’s sovereignty and with reagard to international law and the Swiss Criminal Law. At the end of January 2010 German media promptly reported that German government authorities were considering the „purchase“ for EUR 2.5 million of a CD with illegally otained banking data of customers of a Swiss.

At the beginning of February 2010 Delnon contacted the Swiss authorities, because international law is in force between nations and there is no room for law of the jungle. She suggested reclaiming the illegally procured data by means of a rare state’s claim of Switzerland against Germany at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) as compensation for the breach of international law and treaties by German officials and government representatives. In Delnon’s view the unlawful procurement of secret and legally protected information outside the course of action agreed upon by treaties assumedly breached the Council of Europe Criminal Law Convention on Corruption, the Swiss-German double-tax treaty, the European Convention on Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters, furthermore crimes of espionage against the state of Switzerland, which are liable to prosecution also when committed abroad. But above all such behaviour seemed against the spirit, purpose and wording of the UN Charter and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) as well as the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). The latter were created after the bitter experience of the Second World War in order to safeguard peace from government representatives breaching basic right. These most important ideas mustn’t fall victim to short-term political and financial interests.